SUCCESS STORY
Franciscan University of Steubenville
Why bringing in outside counsel changed everything — before the campaign even began.

Franciscan University’s previous campaign, run without outside counsel, overshot its $75 million goal and raised more than $125 million. So when leadership began planning their next campaign, they couldn’t help but wonder: if they could outperform by that margin without data, what could they achieve with it?
Not wanting to let past success become an artificial ceiling, they engaged Graham-Pelton to conduct a Campaign Confidence Study. This included a wealth screening of 40,000+ prospects, proprietary capacity scoring, and a live vetting session with the Advancement team to layer institutional knowledge onto the data.
The result: $160–227 million in identified philanthropic potential — $50 million more than originally considered.
40,000+ Prospects
Screened
$160–227 Million in
Prospective Gifts Identified
The Situation
Franciscan University of Steubenville had already proven it could raise money. Their previous campaign—run without outside counsel—overshot its $75 million goal and raised more than $125 million. But success can also set an artificial ceiling. After all, if they could outperform by that margin without data, what could they actually achieve with it?
When they reached out to Graham-Pelton to conduct a Campaign Confidence Study, $150 million felt like a meaningful stretch goal, but they wanted to know how much their prospect base could actually support. Were there major donors they’d never identified? People giving elsewhere at levels they’d never approached Franciscan about?
In short, what was their real potential?
The Solution
Graham-Pelton ran a comprehensive wealth screening of 40,436 prospects across Franciscan’s full constituency, including alumni, parents, board members, donors, and friends. We analyzed the raw data against our proprietary capacity scoring model, segmenting and tiering prospects based on giving history and philanthropic indicators.
The result: 2,498 identified major gift prospects with capacity scores ranging from $25,000 to more than $2.5 million, plus an additional 3,893 flagged for qualitative major gift potential.
We then sat down with Franciscan’s Advancement team for a live vetting session, reviewing 70 top-tiered prospects together. In this session, Graham-Pelton and Franciscan’s teams were able to surface a handful of genuinely new names no one had considered at the major gift level. That conversation, layering human knowledge onto quantitative analysis, is where real strategy began.
Our screening and analysis identified $160 to $227 million in philanthropic potential, far more than the original $150 million goal. Across nearly 500 study participants, the data pointed consistently in one direction: Franciscan’s philanthropic potential exceeded what leadership had imagined.
The Success
Based on a full analysis—wealth screening, gift indications, benchmarking, and community sentiment—Graham-Pelton recommended that Franciscan pursue a campaign $50 million more ambitious than what they had initially considered.
More importantly, we mapped the pathway to that goal with clear specificity:
- Lead gifts: $30–40 million
- Strategic discussion participants: $16.5–22 million in gift indications
- E-survey participants: $5.2–7.5 million
- Vetted prospects: $1.9–2.7 million
- Other identified major gift prospects: $78–125 million
- New planned gifts and continued annual giving: $20 million
The analysis also pointed to something beyond the numbers. While study participants expressed strong alignment with Franciscan’s campaign vision, they flagged a consistent need to sharpen the case for support around academic excellence and faculty investment. The data didn’t just tell Franciscan how much they could raise. It told them exactly what would make donors say yes.
Franciscan walked away with more than numbers. They had a clear-eyed picture of who their donors were, what they were capable of, and what would move them to give at a higher level.
Graham-Pelton’s data analytics service combines proprietary wealth screening tools, segmentation modeling, and expert vetting to give advancement teams an honest, actionable picture of their philanthropic potential. We don’t just deliver data; we help you understand what it means for your institution.
Become a Graham-Pelton Success Story
Get the fundraising, data analysis, strategic planning, and campaign management support your higher education institution needs by partnering with Graham-Pelton.